Macklin dole gaffe edit ‘a mistake’
SUE DUNLEVY
News Limited Network
January 02, 201312:00AM
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Print
Email
Watch
Macklin says dole is enough to live on
As changes to Government payments for single parents take effect, the Minister for Families, Jenny Macklin, says she could live on the dole
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
.
.
.
Play
0:00 / 1:06
Scrubber
mute
Share
Fullscreen.
Related Coverage
Welfare groups call for more dole help
I could live on the dole, Macklin declares
‘I could live on the dole’: Minister
Macklin says dole is enough to live on
Dole reforms for disabled fail
Kiwi PM’s accent confuses officials
A SENIOR Federal Government minister’s controversial claim that she could live on the $38-a-day dole has been edited out of an official transcript.
Families Minister Jenny Macklin, a Cabinet member earning $903 a day, pushed 84,000 single mums off the parenting payment and on to the dole yesterday as part of a budget cut designed to save $738 million over four years. The move will cost a single mum who works part-time up to $233 a week.
When asked: “Could you live off the dole?”, Ms Macklin told reporters at the Mercy Hospital in Melbourne: “I could”.
The National Welfare Rights Network immediately challenged the minister to prove it.
“We would welcome the minister taking up the challenge to understand first hand the extreme hardship facing parents raising children alone in difficult circumstances,” National Welfare Rights vice president Kate Beaumont said.
The minister’s claim that she could survive on the dole is at odds with statements by her own ministerial colleagues and puts her under pressure to prove it.
The sensitivity of the remark became clear when a ministerial transcript issued just hours after the event described as “inaudible” the reporters question and the crucial first part of Ms Macklin’s reply. Last night, her office claimed its recording had been affected by a revving car.
The last MP from a major party to put such a claim to the test was National Party MP Stephen Lusher who in 1984 had to concede after a week living on the dole that it couldn’t be cut.
Three parliamentary inquiries, the OECD, the Business Council of Australia, former Treasury Secretary Ken Henry and even Employment Minister Bill Shorten admit the dole is inadequate.
A spokeswoman for Ms Macklin yesterday accepted full responsibility for the transcript ommission.
The minister’s press conference was taped by the spokeswoman on a smart phone and she said a vehicle carrying a camera crew turned up as the press conference was under way, revving its engine.
“It was me trying to transcribe it quickly and get it out using a tape that was not good, I wish I had relistened to it,” the spokeswoman said.
“Her comments are a matter of record and were recorded by a number of television stations,’ she said.
The transcript issued by the minister’s office lists one journalist’s question as inaudible and the minister’s remarks on the dole and two questions after the remark as inaudible. Video footage is crystal clear.
The dole stumble occurred as the minister was trying to publicise another government change that saw fathers of newborn babies eligible to receive up to $1200 in Dad and Partner Pay from January 1.
The cost of prescription medicine also rose on January 1 by 70 cents a script for general patients who will now have to pay $36.10 per script, up from $35.40.
Macklin dole gaffe edit ‘a mistake’
SUE DUNLEVY
News Limited Network
January 02, 201312:00AM
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Print
Email
Watch
Macklin says dole is enough to live on
As changes to Government payments for single parents take effect, the Minister for Families, Jenny Macklin, says she could live on the dole
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
.
.
.
Play
0:00 / 1:06
Scrubber
mute
Share
Fullscreen.
Related Coverage
Welfare groups call for more dole help
I could live on the dole, Macklin declares
‘I could live on the dole’: Minister
Macklin says dole is enough to live on
Dole reforms for disabled fail
Kiwi PM’s accent confuses officials
A SENIOR Federal Government minister’s controversial claim that she could live on the $38-a-day dole has been edited out of an official transcript.
Families Minister Jenny Macklin, a Cabinet member earning $903 a day, pushed 84,000 single mums off the parenting payment and on to the dole yesterday as part of a budget cut designed to save $738 million over four years. The move will cost a single mum who works part-time up to $233 a week.
When asked: “Could you live off the dole?”, Ms Macklin told reporters at the Mercy Hospital in Melbourne: “I could”.
The National Welfare Rights Network immediately challenged the minister to prove it.
“We would welcome the minister taking up the challenge to understand first hand the extreme hardship facing parents raising children alone in difficult circumstances,” National Welfare Rights vice president Kate Beaumont said.
The minister’s claim that she could survive on the dole is at odds with statements by her own ministerial colleagues and puts her under pressure to prove it.
The sensitivity of the remark became clear when a ministerial transcript issued just hours after the event described as “inaudible” the reporters question and the crucial first part of Ms Macklin’s reply. Last night, her office claimed its recording had been affected by a revving car.
The last MP from a major party to put such a claim to the test was National Party MP Stephen Lusher who in 1984 had to concede after a week living on the dole that it couldn’t be cut.
Three parliamentary inquiries, the OECD, the Business Council of Australia, former Treasury Secretary Ken Henry and even Employment Minister Bill Shorten admit the dole is inadequate.
A spokeswoman for Ms Macklin yesterday accepted full responsibility for the transcript ommission.
The minister’s press conference was taped by the spokeswoman on a smart phone and she said a vehicle carrying a camera crew turned up as the press conference was under way, revving its engine.
“It was me trying to transcribe it quickly and get it out using a tape that was not good, I wish I had relistened to it,” the spokeswoman said.
“Her comments are a matter of record and were recorded by a number of television stations,’ she said.
The transcript issued by the minister’s office lists one journalist’s question as inaudible and the minister’s remarks on the dole and two questions after the remark as inaudible. Video footage is crystal clear.
The dole stumble occurred as the minister was trying to publicise another government change that saw fathers of newborn babies eligible to receive up to $1200 in Dad and Partner Pay from January 1.
The cost of prescription medicine also rose on January 1 by 70 cents a script for general patients who will now have to pay $36.10 per script, up from $35.40.
One thought on “Macklin says dole is enough to live on”
Neville
1 January, 2013
Unfortunate remark by Macklin, which will no doubt haunt her.
Talkback radio this morning revealed hardships people are
facing just to live, let alone pay rent and bills and buy food to sustain them. She will regret this remark.