Peter Garrett misled us about literacy statistics – you wouldn’t read about it …


Peter Garrett misled us about literacy statistics – you wouldn’t read about it …

EXCLUSIVE by Katherine Danks and Bruce McDougall
The Daily Telegraph
April 04, 2013 12:00AM

Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size


Peter Garrett

Minister for Schools Education Peter Garrett reacts during Question Time / Pic: Ray Strange Source: The Daily Telegraph

SCHOOLS Education Minister Peter Garrett has exaggerated low literacy levels among Australian students by claiming 30 per cent of pupils entering high school “can’t read or write properly”.

Investigations by The Daily Telegraph have revealed that Mr Garrett is using 1996 assessment data of students in years 3 and 5 to justify increased federal funding in the state school systems.

The statements, made as the government ramped up its discussion about a Gonski funding deal, provide a misleading picture about the achievement level of students entering secondary schools in 2013.

Speaking on ABC’s Lateline on February 25, Mr Garrett said: “A lot of people watching this wouldn’t know that the Australian Council of Educational Research has said to us around 30 per cent of the young people who are going into high school can’t read or write properly. That’s the level of challenge we have, why our education decline is there, and that’s why we need a national plan for school improvement.”Mr Garrett made the same claim in an interview on SkyNews the same day.

Recommended Coverage


Is Swan waging class war?»

THE federal government has been accused of engaging class war rhetoric and stirring up divisions in society with its policies targeting big business and wealthier Australians.


Wealthy SMSFs in Swan tax grab»

THE self-managed super funds of the country’s top income earners are likely to be the key target of the Gillard government’s war against Australia’s so-called “fabulously wealthy”.


PM ‘favoured Disney over hospital’»

WESTERN Sydney MP and victim of Simon Crean’s Ruddless coup Ed Husic has openly criticised Julia Gillard’s decision to give more than $20 million to a Disney film when he has been lobbying in vain for medical equipment for his local hospital.

Tony Abbott.

Abbott gets set for marathon campaign»

A CASHED-UP Tony Abbott plans to launch a 79-day election campaign with the Coalition targeting 43 Labor seats it hopes will secure a crushing victory.

Martin Parkinson.

Inquiry told mining tax ‘deeply flawed’»

TREASURY says it still doesn’t know why revenue from the Federal Government’s mining tax fell so woefully short of its estimations.

Bob Katter.

Key MPs not convinced on super raid»

LABOR risks embarrassment with key crossbenchers leaving the door open to blocking any proposed budget measures for the super sector.

super complaints time.

Hysterical attacks on our retirement»

WITH all the hysteria, you’d be forgiven for thinking our super system is in crisis. When you look at the facts, this is certainly not the case.
. .

Inquiries by The Daily Telegraph failed to turn up any contemporary data showing almost one-third of students “going into high school can’t read or write properly”.

Mr Garrett’s spokeswoman said the statistics, provided to the minister by the department, were based on the Literacy Standards in Australia report, released in 1997.

When asked if it was misleading to use the old report, Mr Garrett’s spokeswoman said “we were not informed it was outdated”.

“The fact still remains that thousands of Australian school students are struggling with literacy,” she said. “This is clear in NAPLAN results, the recent PIRLS (Progress in International Reading Literacy Study) results, and the past decade of decline in international PISA (Programme for International Student Assessment) tests.”

The controversial 1997 report, commissioned by former Liberal education minister David Kemp and prepared by Australian Council for Educational Research, concluded that 73 per cent of year 3 students and 71 per cent of year 5 students met performance standards in reading and writing. It prompted NSW, Victorian, Queensland and Tasmanian ministers at the time to release a joint statement attacking Dr Kemp for “creating a crisis of public confidence in the nation’s schools” and strongly criticising the use of draft benchmarks still under development at that time.

Teachers Federation president Maurie Mulheron yesterday said more recent data such as the Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study (TIMSS) 2011 and the Progress in International Reading Literacy Study (PIRLS) 2011 “would present a more accurate picture”.

The PIRLS report indicates that 24 per cent of year 4 students were below the intermediate benchmark, the minimum proficiency standard, and the TIMSS study concluded our performance in maths and science had largely stagnated over the past 16 years.

According to the latest NAPLAN results, 93.5 per cent of year 3 students across Australia performed above the minimum national standard in reading and 93 per cent in grammar and punctuation. In year 5, 91.8 per cent were above the MNS in reading and 90.4 per cent in grammar and punctuation.

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.