Category: Articles

The Population Myth

admin /11 October, 2009

The Population Myth

People who claim that population growth is the big environmental issue are shifting the blame from the rich to the poor

 

By George Monbiot. Published in the Guardian, 29th Septeember 2009

It’s no coincidence that most of those who are obsessed with population growth are post-reproductive wealthy white men: it’s about the only environmental issue for which they can’t be blamed. The brilliant earth systems scientist James Lovelock, for example, claimed last month that “those who fail to see that population growth and climate change are two sides of the same coin are either ignorant or hiding from the truth. These two huge environmental problems are inseparable and to discuss one while ignoring the other is irrational.”(1) But it’s Lovelock who is being ignorant and irrational.

Global oil reserves and fossil fuel consumption

admin /6 October, 2009

Global oil reserves and fossil fuel consumption

The world is showing no sign of weaning itself off fossil fuels: in the 28-year span covered by the BP data below, worldwide reserves of oil fell only twice – in 1998 and 2008 

Oil wells

Have we passed peak oil? Photograph: David McNew/Getty images

Oil has been the world’s fossil fuel of choice since the late 1960s and our taste for it doesn’t seem likely to diminish in the short term. Oil companies are still keen to secure any undiscovered reserves while continuing to be a powerful lobbying presence.

You may think that with pressing concerns over peak oil and global warming, the world would be slowly weaning itself off the energy-rich liquid. But in the 28-year span covered by the BP data below, worldwide reserves fell only twice – in 1998, and a decade later in 2008.

Opec nations control the lion’s share, with 76% of the world’s reserves. Interestingly, many of the Opec countries’ proven reserves have barely changed in the past 20 years, despite massive exporting activity.

The largest percentage growth in oil wealth is in Vietnam, with a 39% surge in its proven oil reserves from 2007-08. This newfound wealth corresponds to 1.3bn barrels, which may sound like a lot, but would feed the world demand for less than three weeks (17 days) at 2008 levels of consumption.

Stop blaming the poor. It’s the wally yachters who are burning the planet

admin /29 September, 2009

Stop blaming the poor. It’s the wally yachters who are burning the planet

Population growth is not a problem – it’s among those who consume the least. So why isn’t anyone targeting the very rich.

It’s no coincidence that most of those who are obsessed with population growth are post-reproductive wealthy white men: it’s about the only environmental issue for which they can’t be blamed. The brilliant Earth systems scientist James Lovelock, for instance, claimed last month that “those who fail to see that population growth and climate change are two sides of the same coin are either ignorant or hiding from the truth. These two huge environmental problems are inseparable and to discuss one while ignoring the other is irrational.” But it’s Lovelock who is being ignorant and irrational.

Populate and perish: Sydney’s time bomb

admin /19 September, 2009

Populate and perish: Sydney’s time bomb

PAUL BIBBY, MATTHEW MOORE AND JACOB SAULWICK

September 19, 2009

SYDNEY in 2049 will be a vast urban sprawl stretching from Newcastle to Wollongong that as many as seven million people will call home, experts say.

Yesterday’s revelation by the Treasurer, Wayne Swan, that Australia’s population will swell to 35 million in 40 years has forced a reconsideration of whether Sydney can cope.

Demographers from the Australian National University predicted Sydney’s population could grow to 6.9 million by 2049, an increase of 2.6 million.

Food bowl faces stark future

admin /8 September, 2009

Last month, conservative and conservation-minded politicians voted down the Victorian Labor Government’s proposal to assign bulk water entitlements from the Goulburn River to the City of Melbourne. Giovanni Ebono provides the background.

Australia’s water supply is in crisis.

Governments are spending billions on desalination plants, recycling systems and irrigation infrastructure in an attempt to supply water to cities. In the meantime, farmers are being paid to leave the land, leaving once-thriving towns without an income or a future. At the same time the river system is dying.
The Murray River no longer reaches the sea and is rapidly drying out from the mouth up.

Still moving Heaven and Earth to get answers from Plimer

admin /2 September, 2009

Still moving Heaven and Earth to get answers from Plimer

Yes, I’m still trying to move heaven and earth to get answers, but the climate change denier is stepping up his avoidance skiills.

Planet Earth

Hey now, why not simply clarify some questions and try and see the whole picture? Photograph: Corbis

Is Ian Plimer ever going to answer my questions?

As some of your will be aware, I have been engaged in a bit of argy-bargy with the Australian geologist since the beginning of July.

After I criticised some of his crazy statements about climate change, he challenged me to a public debate. After some consideration I agreed, as long as he accepted my challenge: to answer some simple questions about the claims in his book Heaven and Earth.

At first he refused, then, after I wrote an article accusing him of cowardice, he accepted, and said he would address my questions and send me some of his own “after undergraduate lectures have finished today”. This was on Friday 7 August. But no answers came. Instead, on 10 August, he sent me a series of questions he had devised. They were a bizarre collection, which seem to have been designed not to be answered – and, of course, to divert attention from the fact that he wasn’t answering mine. As a couple of commenters on the thread pointed out, he appeared to be using the Chewbacca defence.