The Age’s Alan Moran attacks Vic gov. actions on windmills, but poses some pretty wobbly points
In the Victorian Government’s pre-Christmas issues paper, “Driving
investment in renewable energy in Victoria”, Ministers John Thwaites
and Theo Theophanous said “the Victorian Government has already
committed to” two new renewable energy polices, according to Alan
Moran, a director of the Institute of Public Affairs and a former
Victorian Government deputy energy secretary, in The Age (3/2/2006, p.B10).
Govt’s new policies: These were that:
• Renewable energy is to comprise 10 per cent of Victoria’s electricity consumption by 2010.
• The Government will facilitate the development of up to 1000 megawatts of wind energy by 2006.
Subsidies upon subsidies: These initiatives come on top of a
galaxy of subsidies, supports and concessions already in place. These
measures – established at both state and federal levels – are designed
to assist exotic forms of renewable energy, especially wind power, that
cannot compete in the market. Several political entrepreneurs,
including at least one union super fund, seem to have persuaded the
Bracks Government to force consumers and taxpayers to provide subsidies
for windmills. It surely has been said before but, if wind is really so
efficient, why do we not use sail for commercial shipping? Why did we
abandon the 19th-century clippers in the first place? And why is nobody
contemplating their resurrection?
Costly policies promoting inefficient industry: “Quixotic” is an
appropriate term for Victoria’s energy policy. Ostensibly targeted at
greenhouse gas emissions, it is also, confusingly, designed to promote
an inefficient windmill industry. The outcome can be nothing but
trivial in terms of emission reductions but serious in terms of cost to
Victoria.