Labor’s woolly plan for a referendum on local government at the September 14 federal election has hidden fangs

9 June, 2013 Uncategorized0

Labor’s woolly plan for a referendum on local government at the September 14 federal election has hidden fangs

Your Friends’ Activity

NEW! Discover news with your friends. Give it a try.
To get going, simply connect with your favourite social network:

Facebook
  • twitter
  • linkedin
  • google

This feature allows you to discover news with your friends on Our Network.

This means stories that are read and watched will be shared with your friends, and they’ll share things with you too.

To try out Discover news with friends simply login with your favourite social network. You can login with Facebook, Twitter, Linkedin or Google+

Give it a try! You can turn it off at any time.

Question Time

Speaker of the House Anna Burke during Question Time in the House of Representatives at Parliament House in Canberra. Picture: Gary Ramage Source: The Daily Telegraph

LOCAL government might not sound like a sexy topic (probably because it isn’t) but the federal government’s plan to seek constitutional reform via a referendum at this year’s election is a disgrace, both for the change sought and the process being followed to achieve it.

Voters right across the country should be concerned about plans to give the Commonwealth more power over how local governments spend their money, not to mention enshrining local government in our Constitution.

After all, how many more examples do we need of centrally controlled government schemes being either inefficiently run or downright dangerous?

Don’t get me wrong, I’m no fan of local government administrations. Most “politicians” who serve at the local government level are thoroughly unimpressive to say the least.

But at the moment they are entirely limited by the powers state governments bestow on them.

Constitutional recognition of local government potentially breaks that control while giving the Commonwealth yet another arm of local service delivery that it can stick its nose into.

From the Homepage

I’m filthy over Origin ban

Paul Gallen PAUL Gallen: SO many questions have been thrown my way in the wake of Wednesday night’s State of Origin match.

The real faces of 457 Visas

The real faces of 457 Visas THEY do the jobs most Australians either don’t want or can’t do.

‘Women for Gillard’ funding push

Clarabella BurleyEXCLUSIVE: JULIA Gillard is to launch a new Women For Gillard campaign based on the United States’ successful fundraising movement Women for Obama.

Search goes on as more bodies found

Search goes on as more bodies found THE bodies of 13 asylum seekers have now been sighted by rescuers in the grim search for survivors after an asylum seeker boat tragedy.

Churches denounce anti-vaccine cult

Jane LeonforteEVERY genuine religion in Australia wants parents to vaccinate their kids, from Islam and Judaism to Seventh Day Adventists and Jehovah’s Witnesses.

Kids who just want love

Kids who just want love CEBBY’S full-time carer died when he was eight. Like many other kids in the Northern Territory he just wants and needs to be cared for.

Gym junkies muscle in on power drugs

Peptide UseSPECIAL INVESTIGATION: FITNESS fanatics, teenagers and bikie gangs are driving a massive rise in the use of illegal peptides and hormones.

Michelle and ex still a ‘great team’

Michelle Bridges and Bill Moore THEY may not have succeeded in love, yet in business the relationship between Michelle Bridges and her ex-husband Bill Moore is as happy as ever.

Such a referendum was tried and failed twice before: in 1974 and in 1988.

But at least on those two occasions the government played fair when proposing change, funding both the yes and the no cases.

This time there is a $20 million (taxpayer) funded allotment for the yes case, with not one red penny going towards the no case.

That is a style of democracy more common in Russia than in Australia.

As outrageous as the approach from the Labor government has been on this issue, the opposition has been little better in the way that it has approached the matter.

It signed off in agreement on the referendum “yes” case before it had even seen the wording of the question, and before bothering to ask its party room what it thought about the issue (many MPs have a problem with it, incidentally).

The wording for the referendum question is not that which was thought up by the expert panel which looked into constitutional recognition of local government, nor is it the wording the Joint Select Committee settled on either.

In fact constitutional lawyers who usually disagree on most things are in unison in their opposition to this referendum question, suggesting that such change to the Constitution, if passed, will have a range of adverse unintended consequences.

The answer is simple: vote NO on September 14.

WHAT A BURKE

THE current Speaker of the House of Representatives, Anna Burke, doesn’t seem to understand what the whole point of Question Time is. Let’s just think about it for a moment: to answer questions perhaps? Consider what she told the opposition this week in parliament when it complained that ministers weren’t answering questions: “Question time is not about the answers you are looking for; it is about ministers being relevant to the question.”

No wonder your average voter is so disillusioned with the politics of spin.

TERROR-FYING

SO a convicted jihadist terrorist was held in low security detention in the Adelaide Hills for several months before finally being moved to a more appropriate facility.

The opposition took great delight this week in pointing out that the facility was fenced off by nothing more than a “pool fence”. I’m no fan of the way that the opposition likes to beat up the issue of boat arrivals, but that surely is a pretty extraordinary situation, even if the terrorist never ventured out for a little wine tasting while he was there.

On one hand the poor security appraisal gives rednecks and racists the opportunity to (rather unfairly) tar all asylum seekers with the jihadist brush. On the other hand it was an alarmingly casual approach to how to handle a known terrorist.

SWAN BUSHED

EDUCATION reforms are laudable to say the least, so bravo to Labor for pursuing the much debated Gonski education package.

But perhaps the Deputy Prime Minister needs to sign himself up for a class focused on basic expression, assuming his home state of Queensland decides to sign up to the reforms.

In parliament on Wednesday Wayne Swan not so eloquently said: “We want to ensure that every child gets a good education and none is left behind.”

It reminded me of something that other great wordsmith, former US President George W Bush, once said: “Rarely is the question asked: is our children learning.”

 

 

 

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.