Poor countries walk out of UN climate talks as compensation row rumbles on
- theguardian.com, Wednesday 20 November 2013 22.38 AEST
Representatives of most of the world’s poor countries have walked out of increasingly fractious climate negotiations after the EU, Australia, the US and other developed countries insisted that the question of who should pay compensation for extreme climate events be discussed only after 2015.
The orchestrated move by the G77 and China bloc of 132 countries came during talks about “loss and damage” – how countries should respond to climate impacts that are difficult or impossible to adapt to, such as typhoon Haiyan.
Saleemul Huq, the scientist whose work on loss and damage helped put the issue of recompense on the conference agenda, said: “Discussions were g oing well in a spirit of co-operation, but at the end of the session on loss and damage Australia put everything agreed into brackets, so the whole debate went to waste.”
Australia was accused of not taking the negotiations seriously. “They wore T-shirts and gorged on snacks throughout the negotiation. That gives some indication of the manner they are behaving in,” said a spokeswoman for Climate Action Network.
Developing countries have demanded that a new UN institution be set up to oversee compensation but rich countries have been dismissive, blocking calls for a full debate in the climate talks.
“The EU understands that the issue is incredibly important for developing countries. But they should be careful about … creating a new institution. This is not [what] this process needs,” said Connie Hedegaard, EU climate commissioner.
She ruled out their most important demand, insisting: “We cannot have a system where we have automatic compensation when severe events happen around the world. That is not feasible.”
The G77 and China group, which is due to give a press conference on Wednesday to explain the walkout, has made progress on loss and damage, which it says is a “red line” issue. It claims to be unified with similar blocs including the Least Developed Countries, Alliance of Small Island States and the Africa Group of negotiators.
Hedegaard poured cold water on last week’s related proposal by Brazil, that the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change be asked to find a way to quantify each country’s historical emissions of greenhouse gases in order to help countries establish the level of future emission cuts.
Debate on the issue has been rejected by rich countries, which fear it could lead to unacceptable costs.
Hedegaard conceded that rich countries had a special responsibility to cut emissions. “The whole financing discussion reflects that the developed world knows it has special responsibility. Most of what has been emitted has been done by us,” she said.
Harjeet Singh, ActionAid Internatonal’s spokesman on disaster risk, said: “The US, EU, Australia and Norway remain blind to the climate reality that’s hitting us all, and poor people and countries much harder. They continue to derail negotiations in Warsaw that can create a new system to deal with new types of loss and damage such as sea-level rise, loss of territory, biodiversity and other non-economic losses more systematically.”
Sign up for the Poverty matters email
The most important debate and discussion from around the world delivered every fortnight.
Today’s best video
Mark Gatiss takes us on a tour of the set of An Adventure in Space and Time, which charts the inception and recording of the very first Doctor Who story 50 years ago
Star of Hunger Games sequel on playing Katniss Everdeen
Reviews of Gogglebox, Yonderland, Poirot (left) … and more
Former trade secretary boosted City of Culture bid
- Five small steps to greener technology and travel
We know not everyone can ditch their smartphone, laptop or car, but there are small steps you can take to lessen their effect on the environment.
- Life in the green lane
Driving a car will never be the greenest way to travel but with a little insight, you can save money and cut your environmental impact.